Who’s on First.

I’m not much into warbler watching. They’re fidgety and small.

Plus, the name “warbler” is not cool. Or accurate. These birds chirp.

One spring, I came home and my wife said, “Guess what: there’s a warbler in the house.”

She knows enough to say “warbler,” not just “bird.”

She had a colander in her hand. This seemed an unlikely tool for solving the problem, but it wound up working.

That’s not what this is about, though. This is about comedy.

The little black and white bird, exhausted, sat on an end table and my wife gently set the colander over it. We slid a magazine under, and took it outside.

My wife asked, “What kind was that?”

I said “Black and White.”

And she said, “Yeah, I know it was black and white. And a warbler. But what kind?”

I said, “A Black and White warbler.”

She said. “Yeah, the black and white warbler we just got out of the house. What’s it called?”

I said, “A Black and White Warbler.”

She said, “And I thought you knew about birds.”

This went back and forth. An homage to “Who’s on First,” although we hadn’t intended it to be.

“Who’s on First” is a classic comedy bit performed by Abbott and Costello in the black and white movie era. (It’s on YouTube, if you’re interested).

In any case, the bird’s genuine name is simply “Black and White Warbler.” In a world of stupid bird names, this one’s honest and simple.

If it had been a Red-headed Woodpecker, the name would’ve also been good.

“What kind of woodpecker is that red headed one?”

“Red headed.”

“Yeah, that’s what I said. But what kind?”

And so on.

This spring, Myrtle Warblers are common around here, but have been re-named “Yellow-rumped Warblers.” A step in the right direction. I like the word “rump.”

If one of these warblers gets into my house, and my wife asks me what it is, I’d gladly say, “Yellow-rumped.”

I doubt this would cause us to replay the whole “Who’s on First” routine again. But, we’d remember it.

6 Responses to “Who’s on First.”

  1. Warbler Watcher says:

    re: why isn’t warbler watching hyphenated? We should just call it ‘warbling’ and be done with it.

  2. L. Tom says:

    I hate it when non-birders tell me they saw a black bird with a yellow head and ask what it was. They think I’m mocking when I answer.

  3. Chad Skaggs says:

    This blog is titled “Two-fisted birdwatcher. Makes me wonder: If two-fisted is hyphenized, why not “birdwatcher”?

    And “red-headed” is hyphenated when it’s part of the bird’s name, but not when it’s mere description?

    And “yellow-rumped” has a hyphen at every mention.

    If “bird-watching is hyphenated, why isn’t “warbler watching”?

    Arrrrgh! Bird names are as illogical as is English.

    Cheep cheers,
    Chad
    ———-

  4. Nina says:

    Which reminds me of that same post, can we have a part 2? That blog post still provides so much entertainment for us. Did I mention that I saw a coule of Double Breasted Cowbirds standing in line at Old Country Buffet last week? I had to go to the Radio Shack that’s right next to it. I wanted to take a picture but was afraid I might cause a stampede if my camera flashed.

  5. jeff says:

    Reminds me of the “maine sweatshirt” essay you posted under “shorts”

  6. Food Gappy says:

    Out here in the wild west, we prefer “Butterbutt” to Yellow-rumped Warbler. (with a nod to your “Barkhammer” post)